Best Rug Dupes Revealed: Lookalike Rugs Inspired by Top Brands

Who says luxury style has to cost a fortune? Learn how to find designer-inspired rugs without the designer expense.

Designer Rug Face-Off:

Top Rug Alternatives Uncovered

I’ve always admired the lavish rugs sold at upscale retailers such as Pottery Barn, Magnolia, McGee & Co., and Serena & Lily. However, those price points can certainly be surprising!

When I launched Cottage on Bunker Hill 5 years ago, my aim was to demonstrate how you can create a gorgeous home while staying within your budget. I’m dedicated to helping you get that designer appearance without overspending.

This week, I selected several bestselling rugs from well-known designer retailers and searched online for affordable duplicates with the same aesthetic at a small fraction of the price. And wow, I discovered some incredible options!!

While looking for these wallet-friendly substitutes, I focused on rugs that received favorable customer feedback. Still, although these alternatives look remarkably similar, remember that they won’t match the quality of a $1,500 wool rug purchased from the designer retailer.

Rug Dimension Guide:

Choosing the Ideal Size

Before exploring my rug selections, let’s review a few important basics for deciding what will work in your room. One frequent challenge is choosing the right rug dimensions. A properly proportioned rug can greatly influence a room’s appearance and ambiance.

Living Area Rugs

  • Compact Living Room: A 5×7 or 6×9 rug may be a great fit. Try to position the sofa’s front legs on the rug.
  • Average-Sized Living Room: An 8×10 rug is commonly a smart choice. For a unified appearance, keep all furniture legs on the rug.
  • Spacious Living Room: A 9×12 or larger rug can ground the room. You may want to leave a wide margin around its edges.

Bedroom Area Rugs

  • Set the rug near the foot of the bed. A 5×7 rug is generally adequate for a queen bed. With a king-size bed, think about using a 6×9 or 8×10 rug.
  • For those who want a bigger rug, slide it beneath the bed so part of it extends on both sides. This arrangement can bring a warm, upscale feel to the room.

Dining Area Rugs

  • Smaller Dining Room: Choose a rug that reaches at least 24 inches past every side of the dining table. This gives chairs room to slide out without catching on the rug.
  • Roomy Dining Room: A generously sized rug that fits every chair, including when they are pulled back, lends a more polished and formal appearance.

Pottery Barn Compared with Rug Alternatives

Below are 5 beloved Pottery Barn rugs, along with remarkably similar alternatives I discovered that could save you thousands!




Magnolia Compared with Affordable Rugs


McGee & Co. Compared with Similar Rugs



Serena & Lily Compared with Affordable Rugs



Choosing the ideal rug can completely refresh a room, and it doesn’t need to strain your wallet. With these suggestions and the fantastic lookalikes I’ve featured, you can design a beautiful, fashionable home while staying within your budget. Keep in mind that the secret to selecting the right rug is choosing one that works with your decor and adds happiness to your space.

Enjoy Your Rug Search!

Want to see your projects showcased! If this or another one of my DIY ideas has inspired you, I’d be delighted to view your work and feature you in the Reader’s Spotlight gallery. Email a photo to jennifer@cottageonbunkerhill.com

xo, Jennifer

Printable Artwork

29 Complimentary Downloads

available only to email subscribers

shop these floor coverings!


imitate it until you achieve it

17 Pottery Barn

DIY Ideas for Inspiration

Leave a Comment